Ever been confronted with the whey protein vs plant protein debate? Protein serves crucial body roles: building muscles, skin, bones, blood, and cartilage. It is constructed by amino acids and used by the body and its other useful chemicals to build, repair tissues, produce enzymes e.t.c.
There are two types of peptide supplements: whey and plant-based categories. This article will guide you through the whey protein vs plant protein dilemma and help you choose the best protein powder.
- 1 Understanding Milk Peptides
- 2 Plant-Based Peptides: What are They
- 3 Plant Protein versus Whey Protein: In-depth Comparison
- 4 Nutritional Facts
- 5 Choosing the Right Peptides for You
- 6 Final Thoughts
Understanding Milk Peptides
“Whey” refers to the watery component of milk that is left when curds are formed. It is obtained by filtering milk, drying this concentrate, and turning it into varieties, contained in supplements and powders.
Why Choose Whey?
So what are some pros and cons of whey protein?
- Very digestible and is absorbed into the body faster than other nutrients.
- Combined with strength training, it stimulates muscle growth and repair.
- Contains lactokinins, which helps control blood pressure and insulin response.
- Strengthening the body’s antioxidant defenses by aiding in glutathione production, which is a major antioxidant in the body.
- Helps a lot in losing weight as its consumption leaves you fuller for longer.
- Excessive consumption will cause digestive problems: diarrhea, bloating, flatulence e.t.c.
- When consumed in excess may have substantial adverse effects on your kidneys.
Plant-Based Peptides: What are They
Plant-based peptides are extracted from plants such as pumpkin, peas, chia seeds e.t.c. To make pea biomolecules, the seeds are extracted, processed, and filtered to remove fats and carbs, then the final material dried and used to make the powder.
Why Plant Peptides?
- Plant-based peptides lower the risk of heart disease, as well as lower blood pressure and cholesterol levels.
- Diets in high plant macronutrients will help control weight and protect you from big weight gain.
- When incorporated into meals, plant peptides have been found to improve cholesterol and blood sugar, lowering type 2 diabetes risk.
Negative Side Effects:
- Peptides from plants are of lower quality and require a wider variety of intake to compensate for this.
Plant Protein versus Whey Protein: In-depth Comparison
To clarify the difference between whey protein and plant protein, we’ve made a more in-depth comparison below:
Here’s a nutritional comparison of vegan protein vs whey:
|Nutrient||Whey Protein (32g)||Plant Protein (64g)|
Ease of Digestion
This is the biggest difference between plant protein powder vs whey. Whey is milk-based, hence it will present digestive issues to lactose-intolerant people.
If you can tolerate dairy, milk will be the right choice. It is quickly digested and will repair and build muscle faster. However, if you are lactose-intolerant, pick a plant-based powder. These are free of allergens, gluten-free, and will be absorbed into your body quicker.
The main ingredients in plant-based powders contain pea, seeds, rice, hemp, and quinoa.
Building Muscle Ability
Powders are very popular for weight control. Here’s how plant-based protein vs whey protein works:
Whey peptides offer all the essential 9 amino acids needed for great muscle growth. Plant-based biomolecules do not.
It will also provide BCAAs to your body, which is vital in muscle building food synthesis. These will result in bad taste, but manufacturers add flavors to improve it. The presence of these amino acids in whey will give it an acidic taste, which is not advisable for people with ulcers.
Pea is a major component in most plant-based peptides. It works well to improve muscle thickness as effectively as whey. When combined with ingredients such as hemp and quinoa, it will offer amino acids.
Role in Weight Loss
Several studies have shown whey to be efficient at weight loss. Its consumption reduces ghrelin levels, which is a hormone that signals the brain when you are hungry. This means you will feel satisfied and fuller for longer and end up eating less.
When compared with animal-sourced, plant-based peptides have fewer calories per serving peptides but do not have similar weight loss benefits as those from milk.
Differences in Taste
The taste that you choose will depend on how you want to consume your supplements. If you take it directly, consider a flavored one, but if you incorporate it into food, you can pick an unflavored protein powder as the food will get rid of bad taste.
|Whey protein||Plant protein|
|Digestion||High lactose content makes it difficult to digest||Digestion is easier|
|Weight loss||Reduces ghrelin levels – ideal for weight loss||Is low in calories and does not offer weight loss benefits like whey|
|Nutrition density||Has a lower nutrient density of the essential vitamins||Has a high nutritional density of the essential vitamins|
|Complete protein||Has all of the 9 essential aminos||Does not have the 9 essential aminos and needs to be combined with other plant proteins to be complete|
|BCAA content||Has high BCAA content||Has low BCAA content|
|Detoxification||Has fewer allergies and can therefore be used in detox programs||Cysteine is contained in whey glutathione‘s pioneer, which is a powerful detoxifier.|
|Market trends||Popular with athletes and people into weight training||Popular with vegans and vegetarians.|
Choosing the Right Peptides for You
While making the right choice in plant based protein vs whey protein is mostly subjective, here are some crucial factors to consider:
Always Double Check the Label
It is paramount to always check the ingredients. Choose one that is low in sugar and carbs if you’re trying to lose weight. Stay away from products that contain probiotics.
When shopping, choose products endorsed by the National Sanitation Foundation (NSF) International, as these are labeled as safe for use.
Know and Define Your Goals
The answer in the plant protein vs whey dilemma is highly dependent on the body goals you have in mind. Some powders are made for weight loss, some for weight gain, and others to tame cardiovascular conditions. If you want to lose weight – choose one low in carbs and sugars, and if you want to bulk – pick one that contains BCAA and other amino acids.
Never Ignore Your State of Health
Your health will play a significant role in what powder you choose. If your blood sugar levels are high – find a powder with low sugars and carbs. If you’re lactose intolerant – avoid whey as they contain milk and will cause digestive issues.
If you have kidney issues, pick one with lower levels as kidneys help break down peptides; hence, too much will cause complications. We recommend one with less than 15gms protein per serving.
You should seek your doctor’s advice on how to use whey protein, to avoid any health problems.
For vegans and vegetarians, we recommend plant-based sources.
While the jury is still out on whey protein vs plant protein, the choice you make will ultimately depend on your health, goals, and ingredients. Choose one that will not harm your health and matches your budget.